Alternatives to Reward Charts: 10 Ways to Positively Nurture Children

As parents, it's only natural to want the best for your child, including their behaviour and development. Over the years, many well-meaning parents and caregivers have turned to reward charts as a tool to encourage good behaviour in their young ones. However, modern research suggests that there are more effective, long-lasting ways to nurture children.

In this article, we'll explore the potential adverse effects of reward charts and provide alternative strategies to promote positive behaviour and development throughout your child’s precious early years.

The Pitfalls of Reward Charts

Reward charts, also known as sticker charts or star charts, are designed to motivate children to achieve specific goals or display certain behaviours by offering rewards such as stickers or small treats. While they may provide short-term compliance, there are potential downsides to relying solely on reward charts, such as:

  • Overemphasis on Extrinsic Motivation: Reward charts primarily focus on external rewards, which can lead children to act in the desired way solely to earn stickers or treats rather than understanding the intrinsic value of good behaviour.
  • Short-Term Compliance: Children may lose interest in reward charts over time, leading to a decline in desired behaviour once the rewards lose their appeal.
  • Limitation of Self-Regulation: Reward charts do not inherently teach children self-regulation and intrinsic motivation, which are crucial life skills. They may learn to behave only when they expect a tangible reward.
  • Potentially Stressful: Some children may feel pressured to earn rewards, leading to undue anxiety and stress. As such, reward charts can have an adverse effect on children’s confidence and overall wellbeing.
  • Diminished Intrinsic Joy: Constantly seeking external validation can overshadow the joy of performing good deeds simply for the satisfaction of being kind or helpful.

10 Alternative Strategies to Encourage Positive Behaviour

  1. Positive Reinforcement through Praise

    Instead of relying on physical rewards, use verbal praise to acknowledge your child's positive actions. Celebrate their achievements with words of encouragement and affection. This helps them internalise a sense of accomplishment.

  2. Model the Behaviour

    Children learn by example, so it’s helpful to demonstrate the behaviours and values you want them to adopt. When they see you practising kindness, respect, and good manners, they are more likely to follow suit and normalise these behaviours for themselves.

  3. Effective Communication

    Engage your child in open and honest, age-appropriate conversations. When an opportunity for learning presents itself, discuss the importance of certain behaviours and help them to understand the reasons behind them. Remember to use simple and clear examples relevant to your child’s life in order to help drive your teaching home. Always encourage your child to ask questions and express their feelings.

  4. Consistent Boundaries

    Set clear and consistent boundaries. Like adults, children thrive when they understand what is expected of them. So, be patient but firm in implementing rules and consequences when necessary.

  5. Use Natural Consequences

    Allow your child to experience the natural consequences of their actions, whenever safe and possible. This helps them learn cause-and-effect relationships and to develop problem-solving skills.

  6. Encourage Empathy

    Teach your child about empathy by helping them to understand how their actions can affect those around them. Encourage them to consider how someone else might feel and why it's important to be mindful, kind and considerate.

  7. Create a Supportive Environment

    Ensure your child's environment is conducive to positive behaviour. Provide opportunities for them to explore their interests, express creativity, and engage in meaningful activities. Nursery and playdates make for wonderful social environments where your child to learn about themselves and others and develop their interpersonal skills.

  8. Support Independence

    Give your child age-appropriate responsibilities and the chance to make choices. Whether it’s allowing them to pick their clothing for the day or asking them to put their toys away, this helps build their sense of autonomy and responsibility.
  1. Quality Time

    Spend as much quality time together as a family as possible. This not only strengthens the parent-child bond but also allows you to model values and reinforce positive behaviour.
  1. Consider Professional Guidance

    If you encounter persistent behavioural challenges, you may want to consider seeking guidance from your child’s key person at nursery, their paediatrician, a child psychologist, or child development experts. They can provide insight and personalised strategies and support.

So, while reward charts may offer short-term behavioural improvements, they may not be the most effective method for nurturing your child's long-term development and character. They may also contribute to your child’s mental health by adding undue pressure or inciting the feeling of not being ‘good enough’. Instead, try to focus on building a foundation of intrinsic motivation, positive reinforcement, and open communication.

By trying these alternative strategies, you can empower your child to develop self-regulation, empathy, and a lifelong commitment to positive behaviour and values. It's all about nurturing your child's development, one thoughtful step at a time!

If you enjoyed this article and found it to be useful, you can check out more of our early childcare resources in our Family Resource Zone!

And, if you’re not yet a Bright Horizons parent, but are interested in what our nurseries can offer your child on their exciting educational journey, book a personal tour at your local nursery today!